Published on:

Denied Warranty Coverage for a Simmons or Serta Mattress Due to a “Stain”? You’re Not Alone.

For many consumers, warranty coverage is one of their primary concerns when spending thousands of dollars on a new mattress. Due to the expense involved—memory foam mattresses cost upwards of $5,000, and even traditional pillow-top mattresses retail for over $1,000—consumers want to know that they can depend on the manufacturer to repair or replace a mattress under warranty for years following purchase. Tempur-pedic and Sleep Number offer twenty-five-year warranties to entice consumers to purchase their products. Serta and Simmons—both of which are owned by the National Bedding Company—also offer long warranties ranging anywhere from 3 to 30 years and include no charge for replacements within the first 10 or so years of ownership.  These long-term warranties should give consumers as much comfort as the mattresses themselves!

Consumers report in droves, however, that Simmons and Serta routinely deny warranty coverage due to the presence of any stain, no matter how small or harmless, on a defective mattress. Don’t believe us? Just listen to some of the incredible stories from affected consumers (postings from www.consumeraffairs.com):

  • After owning a Serta “Beautyrest World Class Recharge Shakespeare Luxury Plush Pillow top Mattress” for about two years, and paying over $2000, the mattress was sagging. So I called Serta, and they send you a “sleep set inspection kit” where you have run a string across the dips in the mattress and take photos from different angles. After doing all this they agreed to replace the mattress. When their team arrived they said that they couldn’t take the mattress because of a small stain!! I called Serta, and was told that the stain voided the warranty because it wasn’t sanitary for their inspection team to open the mattress up and see where the mattress failed. The product was an inferior product with a huge manufacturers defect, and because of a small stain (barley visible) which had nothing to do with the sagging, was a loophole they used to void the warranty. I WILL NEVER BUY ANOTHER SERTA PRODUCT BECAUSE THEY DON’T STAND BEHIND IT!!!
  • We purchased this mattress between 2 and 3 years ago. It has not held up. There are sags and dips plus a back ache to people sleeping on it. It should be covered by a warranty issue except a small stain gets the Beautyrest folks off the hook. Never, never, would I buy from this manufacturer again. This was in our bedroom and we moved it to a guest room buying a replacement. Please note the Beautyrest replaced a mattress which had been in our room over 25 years. Since putting it in the guest room, two different guests mentioned waking up with a back ache. There are other options… Select one.

But even more frustrating for consumers who have had warranty coverage denied by Simmons and Serta due to small mattress stains: Serta and Simmons preclude customers from cleaning their mattresses or protecting them with any sort of fabric sealer! Both warranties state that cleaning your mattress or using any “fabric protection stain” also will void your warranty. As a result, Serta and Simmons customers who have had warranty coverage denied due to mattress stains are caught between a rock and a hard place (or, rather, a rock and a mattress): don’t protect your mattress and lose warranty coverage, or use a mattress cover that leads to uncomfortable sleep and wrinkled sheets and can cost upwards of $100.

Were you denied warranty coverage for a Simmons or Serta mattress only because the mattress was stained? If so, we’d like to speak with you and discuss your rights.